This guide is for WordPress site owners, bloggers and small-business marketers who want a calm, repeatable way to deal with broken links. There are two separate problems hiding under that phrase, and they need different fixes. The first is links on your own pages that lead to a dead address. The second is addresses on your site that return “not found” when someone or something requests them, such as an old URL that another site still links to. Google’s documentation is fairly relaxed about the second kind.
Two kinds of broken link
The fix depends on which one you have.
- Broken links on your pages. A post links to an internal page that was deleted or renamed, or to an outside site that has moved or gone offline. Visitors who click land on an error. You control these links, so you can fix every one of them.
- 404s that arrive from elsewhere. Another site, an old bookmark or an old version of your own site points to a URL that no longer exists. You cannot edit the link, but you can decide what your server returns for that address.
What Google says about 404s
Google’s page on HTTP status codes and network errors says that 404 and 410 are treated the same way: the content is considered nonexistent. If the URL was indexed, it is removed from the index. URLs that Google newly encounters with a 404 are not processed, and crawling of them gradually decreases. Content returned with a 4xx response is ignored.
An older Google Search Central post, “Do 404s hurt my site?” (published in 2011, so treat it as background rather than current documentation), makes the reassuring point that a 404 alone does not count against you in search results and does not change how your other pages perform.
The Search Console Help page for the Page indexing report says the same thing in practical terms: a 404 is not necessarily a problem if the page was removed without any replacement. It suggests fixing only 404s for URLs that you link to yourself or list in a sitemap.
Soft 404s are the ones to watch
A soft 404 is a page that shows a “not found” message, or almost no content, but sends a normal success status (2xx) to the browser. Google’s status-code page says Search Console will flag these as soft 404 errors. The 2011 post warns that soft 404s can hurt how your site is understood and indexed.
On WordPress this can happen when a theme or plugin shows an error message but still returns success. The Search Console fix is to return a real 404 for pages that are truly gone. For a page that should exist, add real content so it stops looking like an error page.
Find 404s with the Page indexing report
If you have not connected your site yet, start with our guide to setting up Google Search Console on a WordPress site. Then:
- Open Search Console and choose your property.
- Go to the Page indexing report and scroll to the table of reasons pages are not indexed.
- Open Not found (404) and review the example URLs. The report only shows URLs that returned a 404 in the past month, according to the Help page.
- Open Soft 404 if it appears and review those URLs separately.
- Sort each URL into one of the three outcomes described below.
Many will be old addresses that never mattered. Google may keep retrying a 404 URL for a while and will crawl it less often over time, but the Help page says you cannot permanently tell Googlebot to forget a URL.
Check a single URL with URL Inspection
Paste the full address into the inspection bar at the top of Search Console, or click the inspect icon next to a URL in a report. The default result reflects Google’s most recent crawl, not a live test.
Click Test live URL to fetch the page in real time. This is how you confirm a fix: the live test shows whether the URL is now available to Google, and View tested page shows the rendered screenshot, raw HTML and HTTP headers. The Help page notes that live tests have a daily limit per property.
Decide: update the link, redirect, or let it 404
| Situation | Best action | Why |
|---|---|---|
| One of your own pages links to a dead internal URL | Edit the link to point to the current URL | Cleaner than relying on a redirect, and you control the link. |
| A page moved or was renamed, and old links exist elsewhere | 301 redirect to the new URL | Visitors and Google reach the right page. Google’s docs call a 301 a strong signal that the target should be processed. |
| A page was removed and has a close replacement | 301 redirect to that replacement | Google lists “removing a page and sending users to a replacement” as a use for redirects. |
| A page was removed with no replacement | Leave the 404 (or return 410) | Google treats 404 and 410 the same, and says a 404 is not necessarily a problem. |
| An outside link on your page is dead | Replace it with a working source, or remove the link | Visitors hit a dead end, and you can edit it. |
When a redirect is the wrong choice
Redirect only when the destination is a real match for what the visitor wanted. Sending every dead URL to the homepage may look tidy, but Google’s soft 404 guidance in Search Console is to return a real 404 for pages that are gone. If you cannot name a genuinely related page, a 404 is the honest answer.
When you do redirect, use a permanent one (301, or its equivalent 308) for a move that is final. Google’s redirect documentation says a permanent redirect makes Google show the target in search results, so use it only when you are confident the change will not be reverted. For a step-by-step method, see our guide to setting up 301 redirects on WordPress safely. Google follows up to 10 redirect hops, so avoid chains.
Fixing broken links on your own pages
Search Console does not list dead links inside your posts, so you need another way to find them. Options include a link-checker plugin, an external crawler or a manual review of your most important pages. This guide does not recommend a specific product.
A caution about scanning on a WordPress plugin: checking every link means making many requests, which can be heavy on cheap shared hosting. If your site slows down while a scan runs, schedule it for a quiet time, scan less often or use an external crawler instead. If hosting limits are a recurring problem, our piece on finding the right cheap hosting plan covers what to look for.
Check each reported link by hand first, since links can fail temporarily or block automated checks. Then apply the same decision as above.
A simple routine
- Before deleting or renaming a page, decide what should happen to its old URL: redirect to a close replacement, or let it 404.
- Monthly: open the Page indexing report, check Not found (404) and Soft 404, and look only for URLs you link to or list in your sitemap.
- Quarterly: run a link check on your site at a quiet hour and fix internal links first, then outside ones.
- After a fix: use URL Inspection to test the live URL, and use Validate fix in the report. The Help page says validation can take up to about two weeks.
- When you update older posts, check their links as part of the job. Our guide to refreshing old blog posts fits naturally here.
Key takeaways
- Separate broken links on your pages (always fix) from 404s other sources send to you (fix only when it matters).
- Google says a 404 for a removed page with no replacement is not necessarily a problem, and treats 404 and 410 alike.
- Redirect with a 301 only to a genuinely relevant page; otherwise let the page 404.
- Soft 404s deserve attention: return a real 404 for missing pages, or add real content to pages that should exist.
- Use the Page indexing report monthly, URL Inspection to verify, and a link checker occasionally, with care on weak hosting.
FAQ
Do 404 errors hurt my rankings?
According to Google’s 2011 post, a 404 alone does not count against your site and does not change how your other pages perform. Google’s current status-code page says an indexed URL that returns 404 is removed from the index.
Should I use a 404 or a 410?
For Google Search the result is the same, because it treats 404 and 410 alike. Use whichever your setup makes easiest.
Why does a 404 stay in Search Console after I fix it?
Googlebot may keep trying a URL for a while and crawls it less often over time. If the page now exists or redirects correctly, click Validate fix and allow up to about two weeks.
Is a link-checker plugin necessary?
No. It is one way to find dead links. An external crawler or a manual review of key pages also works.
